Broker Check
Weekly Update:  The Cost of Disorder and the Discipline of Staying the Course

Weekly Update: The Cost of Disorder and the Discipline of Staying the Course

May 14, 2026

Watch our full Weekly Market Recap here.

Markets test discipline when uncertainty rises and clarity fades. Prices move faster than explanations. Headlines spread before facts settle. Investors feel the urge to act, not because they see opportunity, but because they want relief. That instinct creates more damage than the volatility itself. History, philosophy, and market behavior all point to the same conclusion. External disorder rarely causes the greatest harm. Internal disorder does.

Last week delivered a clear example. Economic data showed a mixed but still resilient economy. Manufacturing activity slowed, with PMI coming in at 53.6, while employers added 115,000 jobs. That combination signals moderation, not collapse. On its own, that data does not justify panic. But markets do not operate in isolation. They absorb shocks from outside the economic system. Right now, geopolitical risk drives the narrative.  The closure of the Strait of Hormuz changed the equation. That narrow corridor carries roughly 20% of global oil flows. When it shuts, energy markets react immediately. Oil prices surged, with WTI crude peaking at $112 per barrel. Higher energy prices feed inflation expectations and strain global supply chains. This disruption does not sit on the sidelines. It moves directly into the core of the global economy.

Global policymakers responded quickly, but their tools have limits. The International Energy Agency announced the largest coordinated release of emergency oil reserves in history, totaling 400 million barrels. That sounds massive, but scale matters. The world consumes about 100 million barrels per day. This release covers roughly four days of global demand, or about twenty days of the oil that normally flows through the Strait of Hormuz. Policymakers bought time. They did not solve the problem.  Markets responded in layers. First, they adjusted mechanically. Energy prices rose. Equities repriced. Bond yields shifted. Then, investors layered emotion on top of those moves. Some saw risk and moved to safety. Others saw opportunity and leaned into volatility. That divergence created the volatility itself.

Equity markets reflected that tension. Major indices posted gains, even as geopolitical risks escalated. The S&P 500 rose 2.36%, and the NASDAQ gained 4.52%. That performance does not ignore risk. It reflects expectations. Markets price future conditions, not current headlines. Investors weighed the likelihood that disruptions would eventually stabilize against the immediate uncertainty.  Sector performance told a more detailed story. Technology led the market higher, while other sectors showed mixed results. That divergence highlights an important truth. Markets do not move in straight lines from cause to effect. They move through expectations, positioning, and sentiment. By the time a trade looks obvious, it often loses its edge.  Fixed income markets reinforced the idea that the system continues to adjust rather than break. Treasury yields remained relatively stable, with the 10-year holding in the mid 4% range. Credit markets did not show signs of severe stress. If investors believed a deep recession loomed, they would have rushed into safe haven assets more aggressively. That did not happen. Investors priced risk, but they did not panic.

This is where behavior becomes the deciding factor. Market conditions create the environment, but investor decisions determine outcomes. Oil at $90 or $110 matters less than how investors respond to the volatility around it.  The Stoics understood this dynamic long before modern markets existed. Seneca wrote that “the greatest portion of peace of mind is doing nothing wrong,” and he warned that people who lack self-control live disoriented lives. That insight applies directly to investing. Discipline creates order. Impulse creates chaos.  . A fugitive often turns themselves in, not because they lose physical freedom, but because they cannot bear the psychological burden any longer. The constant stress becomes its own prison. Investors create a similar trap when they abandon discipline. They escape short term volatility only to enter long term regret.

This pattern repeats.  Investors sell during downturns to avoid further losses. Then they miss the recovery that follows. They chase performance after markets rebound. They buy high and sell low, all while believing they act rationally in the moment. The behavior feels justified. The results say otherwise.  Investors must treat discipline as a strategy, not a personality trait. They must align their actions with long term objectives rather than short term emotions. They must follow evidence rather than headlines. They must commit to a plan that anticipates uncertainty instead of reacting to it.  Financial planning provides that structure. It connects investment strategy, tax planning, income design, and estate considerations into a unified system. Each component reinforces the others. Together, they create resilience.

Tax planning plays a central role in that system. Retirement accounts illustrate the challenge. Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) begin in your early seventies and increase over time. At age 73, the distribution may sit near 4% of the account value. By age 85, it can exceed 6%. Those distributions add to Social Security and other income sources, pushing retirees into higher tax brackets.  The widow penalty compounds the issue. A surviving spouse moves from married filing jointly to single status, often while retaining most of the household income. That shift increases effective tax rates and can trigger higher Medicare surcharges. Investors who ignore this dynamic leave themselves exposed.  The SECURE Act adds another layer. Most non-spouse beneficiaries must withdraw inherited IRAs within ten years. Those withdrawals often occur during peak earning years, pushing beneficiaries into higher tax brackets. Without planning, a lifetime of tax deferral can turn into a decade of tax acceleration.

Investors must address these risks proactively. They cannot wait for the problem to arrive. They must integrate tax strategy into their broader plan.  That integration creates opportunity, especially during volatile markets. Lower asset values can make Roth conversions more efficient. Investors can shift future taxable income into tax free structures at a reduced cost. Tax loss harvesting can offset gains and reduce current liabilities. These strategies require planning and discipline. They do not work when investors react emotionally.  Income planning also demands attention. A portfolio focused solely on growth may struggle to produce stable income during volatility. A portfolio concentrated in fixed income may fail to keep pace with inflation. Investors must build diversified income streams. Dividends, interest, real estate income, and strategic withdrawals must work together. That structure reduces reliance on any single source.

Resilience becomes the goal. Investors cannot eliminate risk. They can prepare for it. A resilient plan anticipates multiple outcomes and remains functional across them.  The current geopolitical environment reinforces that reality. The closure of the Strait of Hormuz demonstrates how quickly conditions can change. Energy flows influence inflation. Inflation influences central bank policy. Policy influences interest rates. Rates influence asset valuations. Each layer interacts with the others. Investors must navigate the entire system, not just one piece of it.  Strategic oil reserves provide a useful analogy. Countries maintain reserves to manage disruptions, not eliminate them. Those reserves provide time and flexibility. But they remain finite. Leaders must use them carefully.

Investors should think the same way about their financial plans. Cash reserves, diversification, tax strategies, and insurance create flexibility. They allow investors to make rational decisions during stressful periods. They do not prevent volatility. They help investors navigate it.  The greatest risk remains behavioral. Volatility tests discipline. Investors who maintain their plan position themselves to benefit from long term growth. Investors who react emotionally often lock in losses and miss recoveries.  The Stoics framed this as a matter of control. Control what you can. Accept what you cannot. Act with intention. In markets, investors cannot control geopolitical events or short-term price movements. They can control their behavior, their planning, and their discipline.  There will always be another crisis. Another headline will replace the Strait of Hormuz. Markets will face new shocks. Stability will remain temporary. Change will remain constant.

Investors should not aim to predict every change. They should build plans that endure change. They should maintain discipline when uncertainty rises. They should act with clarity when others react with fear.  The cost of disorder extends beyond market losses. It shows up in missed opportunities, unnecessary taxes, abandoned strategies, and diminished long-term outcomes. The reward of discipline extends beyond returns. It provides confidence, clarity, and the ability to move through uncertainty with purpose.  Markets will continue to test that discipline. The question is simple. Will investors stay aligned with their plan, or will they let volatility pull them off course?

The answer will determine not just their returns, but their experience along the way.

Click HERE for charts and disclosures.Charts & Disclosures Available Here